|
Status ❧ Dept. of Ex-Religious Studies
Why being treated fairly isn’t the same as being treated well.
Jonathan Malesic spent his twenties and most of his thirties chasing tenure. He got it. He hated it. He quit. He needed to know why.
His desperate attempt to reconcile who he wanted to become (Professor of Religious Studies) and who he became (not that) led him to believe his ideals made him a poor match for the requirements of his role. He now preaches the gospel of the personal pivot and argues that people who seek dignity, mastery, and purpose should fear the consequences of succeeding professionally. Just because employment is pitched as a character-building test, doesn’t mean it really is one.
Upper Middle spoke to Malesic, about burnout, The End of Burnout, and the importance of not-work.
For someone reading this who's working long hours and assuming the exhaustion is a problem about time or workload, what's a diagnostic for mismatch-driven burnout? I've worked most of my life in academia and I've talked to a lot of academic audiences about burnout. The first thing I always have them do before they hear a word from me is talk to each other about why they got into this line of work in the first place. That's an exercise in articulating your ideals. Money can be an ideal. But there are other ideals too.
We should check periodically: What am I hoping to get out of this job? What am I hoping to get out of my career? What financial, psychological, social, moral, and even spiritual goods ideals am I pursuing? Will I actually get them?
A version of that diagnostic the audience for this newsletter may not love hearing is.. The mismatch is probably not between what you’re worth and getting paid what you’re worth. Getting paid just doesn’t paper over everything else that might be going wrong in your job. You can't earn your way out of burnout. If money becomes a really big concern — especially for highly educated professionals who are really worried about what they're being paid — I will bet there's something else deeply wrong in their job. They're looking to pay to compensate for that. They may not be able to.
In a well-functioning workplace, people are paid such that they don't have to think about what they're being paid. They're focused on other things.
Where can upper-middle-class professional whose identities havebeen fused with their careers since college actually start looking for the alternative source of mastery and meaning? In the last year and a half, I decided for no real reason to start learning French. For over a year, I went in person every Saturday morning to the Alliance Francaise and saw almost the exact same people. It's slow, but I'm building real mastery. I'm about to finish the sixth complete book in French that I've read. I could not have done that a year ago. Now I can. It feels great.
Opportunities for building mastery are everywhere. They might just not be at work.
There's a specific pattern among the people where work bleeds into a kind of optimization culture, and the whole self becomes a project. Is that the same disease as burnout, or a different one? Very often, in order to express that we value a thing, we call it work. We call marriage work. We call parenting work. We call school work. We call mental health work. We even call death and dying work. And if anything is not work, it's definitely dying. You don't have to try.
There are, of course, work-like elements to all of those things. There's effort. In some cases there are structures. But it's a real failure of imagination to understand these things as valuable only insofar as they resemble our work. What we need to do is expand the realm of not-work — leisure, plus a third category, worthy activities that have an element of mastery but aren't remunerative.
Burnout has now become a vocabulary item used for everything from clinical exhaustion to a bad Tuesday. Has the inflation of the term made the real condition harder to recognize? Definitely. We minimize real problems with our work when we see burnout everywhere. If someone is genuinely burned out, the cure is going to be a fairly radical — at minimum a new schedule, maybe different responsibilities, maybe a different role in the organization, maybe a new job, maybe a completely new career. It often takes a pretty big change to address a serious case.
When I hear people say, ‘Boy, I was really burned out last week.’ I think to myself: ‘Just for a week? That's great. What's your secret?’ It minimizes. It becomes harder to see the people who are struggling when everyone is uses the term so casually.
Jonathan Malesic's The End of Burnout argues that burnout is what happens when modern jobs fail to confer dignity, meaning, and identity – despite sometimes paying pretty good. If answering emails has been a bit of a slog of late, you might want to give it a read.
|